Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It Case Study

Medical Tests and the Ethical Implications Associated with It - Case Study Example The researcher states that according to act utilitarianism it is our duty to act in a way that will produce better consequences. If Camilla decides to get herself tested, then this act of hers will definitely produce better results, mainly in the form of her protecting the future of her kids. Another important point which should be noted here is that, according to act utilitarianism, the correctness of an act should be judged by the consequence. Thus even if the act of forcing Camilla is wrong on the moral front, the consequence of it is not. If her parents force her to take the test, the good consequence that will come out of it in the form of Camilla taking extra care when planning her kids will nullify the negativity of the way she was forced to take the test. Thus we should determine right and wrong internally through autonomy and self-law. The individual himself should determine what he wants to do, which is what Camilla should do. According to Kantianism, Camilla should not go and get her tests done just because the consequences of it would be right. But she should get the tests done because it is right to do so. Kantianism is not consequential. Actions depend on a person’s motive and intentions. Camilla does not want to be labeled as a positive hemophilia carrier. She views this as a negative consequence. However, according to Kantianism, what she should focus on is why she wants to get the test done, not what would be the outcome. She should focus on the fact that if she gets the tests done right now, she will be better prepared to look after her kids later on in life. Thus for the safety and well being of her kids, she should go and get her tests done. However, she should do it only because she thinks its right and not because someone else is forcing her to do so.